What were the arguments for and against federation?

Thanks for your question. Before 1901 Australia was not a nation but a collection of 6 British colonies. The colonies were almost like separate countries; for example, each had its own government and laws, its own defence force, issued its own stamps and collected tariffs – taxes – on goods that crossed its borders. In the late 1800s, people began to debate if the colonies should join together to form one nation. Some of the areas where people felt strongly for or against Federation were:

  • The capacity of a strong national government to manage issues such as trade, the economy, defence and immigration.
  • The cost of setting up and running an Australian Parliament.
  • Concerns we would lose our cultural ties to England and the emerging cultural identities of the 6 colonies would be lost.
  • The benefits that would come from centralising services such as railways and post.
  • The benefits that would come from removing the taxes and duties on goods moving between the colonies/states.
A painting of a man wearing a formal hat and uniform standing and speaking to a large crowd inside a large building. The painting shows many people on stage behind the man, and many more people standing in front of the stage watching him.

Opening of the First Parliament of the Commonwealth of Australia by H.R.H. The Duke of Cornwall and York (Later King George V), May 9, 1901.

Parliament House Art Collection, Canberra, ACT and the Royal Collection Trust.

Opening of the First Parliament of the Commonwealth of Australia by H.R.H. The Duke of Cornwall and York (Later King George V), May 9, 1901.

A painting of a man wearing a formal hat and uniform standing and speaking to a large crowd inside a large building. The painting shows many people on stage behind the man, and many more people standing in front of the stage watching him.

Parliament House Art Collection, Canberra, ACT and the Royal Collection Trust.

Description

This painting was painted by Australian artist Tom Roberts. It is known as the 'Big Picture', although its official name is 'Opening of the First Parliament of the Commonwealth of Australia by H.R.H. The Duke of Cornwall and York (Later King George V), May 9, 1901.' 

The ‘Big Picture’ includes 269 portraits of the people who attended the opening of the First Parliament, including the Governor-General, the members of the Senate and House of Representatives, and Australia’s first Prime Minister, Edmund Barton.